We call the third posture by its research name, appreciative followership: an orientation toward inquiry, strengths and co-creation, enacted from the follower role.1 It expands the repertoire and does not replace the other two. It is a capacity people can learn, not a personality trait. It needs no title, because the same person may lead a project in the morning and follow a colleague in the afternoon.1
Start with one focused change.Watch it spread through the whole organization.
For organizations of every kind.
Seven signals an organization is ready for change.
Most organizations do not call when things are calm. They call at one of these moments, usually more than one at once.
- 2.1
A strategy that never left the boardroom
It was approved, but people cannot say what it changes about their week.
- 2.2
A structure the organization outgrew
Roles, decisions and communication were built for a smaller organization. Structure and leadership decide where authority sits and how power is used.2
- 2.3
Leaders and staff on opposite sides
An "us and them" split between the leadership team and everyone else, with trust running out.2
- 2.4
New leaders inheriting old habits
Leaders promoted without development can copy the leadership team they join, including its worst habits.2
- 2.5
People who comply but do not contribute
Programs designed at the top can produce performative compliance instead of real participation.1
- 2.6
Fixes that do not hold
A new rule or policy is applied to a problem that needs people to rethink how they work, and the problem comes back.4
- 2.7
Results in decline
Performance is sliding and the usual fixes are not working.
Ten elements, one system.
An organization behaves something like an atom. Its elements are bound together, and a change in any one shifts the energy, balance and identity of the whole.2 So our assessment never looks at one element alone. We examine all ten, and how each one is acting on the others.
The element names are the source's.2 The one-line descriptions are ours, except where a note is given.
- 3.1
Culture
The shared mindsets, values and norms of behaviour that most people in the organization hold.2 In the model it surrounds every other element.
- 3.2
Teamwork
How people work together within groups and across them. In the model it sits at the core.
- 3.3
Leadership
How leaders influence, decide and use power.2
- 3.4
Structure
Where formal authority and decisions sit.2
- 3.5
Systems
The processes, information flows and rewards that carry the work.
- 3.6
Human factors
How the work fits the people who do it, physically and mentally.
- 3.7
Strategy
The choices about where to go, and what to stop doing.
- 3.8
Mission
What the organization exists to do.
- 3.9
Vision
The future it is working toward.
- 3.10
Environment
The conditions outside: funders, regulators, markets, congregations, communities.
| Question | One kind | The other kind | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical or adaptive? | Solvable with known expertise or a new procedure | Needs the people facing it to revise norms and beliefs | Treating an adaptive problem as a technical one wastes scarce resources and leaves the problem in place.4 |
| Said or done? | What the organization says it values | What happens in daily decisions | A gap between the two weakens trust and silences voice.1 A claimed leadership philosophy does not show how leaders actually lead.8 |
| Failing or working? | What is broken | What is already working | We build the plan on strengths the assessment finds, not only on gaps.1 |
The Catalyst Cycle.
Our method for every engagement. It begins with the whole-system assessment and follows a modified Appreciative Inquiry cycle,1 so the people who live with the change help design it. Four stages hold seven phases.
01 Listen
Develop · Define · Discover
We build shared understanding and readiness with the people involved, agree what the work is for, and assess all ten elements through interviews, observation and the organization's own records. Listening is already an intervention: the questions we ask start to move the system.1,6
02 Plan
Dream · Design
Leaders and staff from across levels imagine what could be and design it together, building on the strengths the assessment found. We also choose the approach the situation calls for (directed, planned or iterative),3 and we prepare the sponsoring leaders for the participative moments ahead.7
03 Act
Deliver
The people who designed the plan carry it out, in cross-level teams, while we coach leaders to share authority with the knowledge held elsewhere in the system.1
- You receive
- Facilitation, coaching and regular progress reviews.
- Grounding
- Deliver, which in the source replaced the classic Destiny phase to put the weight on implementation.1
04 Sustain
Drive
When people design and deliver a change themselves, they tend to carry the practices into other teams and other work. The source describes this continuing after the facilitated work ended.1 We plan for it from the start, and we do not stop too early: ending a change effort prematurely is a major risk.3
Comply, resist, or build.
Most thinking about followers places them on a line from compliance to resistance: go along, or push back.1 Both have their place. There are moments to defer to legitimate authority and moments for courageous refusal. But both are reactions to something leaders started. Recent research names a third posture.1
- 5.1
Compliance
Takes the current reality as given and works within it.1
- 5.2
Resistance
Takes the current reality as a problem and works against it.1
- 5.3
Generative co-creation
Asks what is already working, what could be possible, and what people could build together, then helps design it. It shapes the organization instead of only responding to it.1
Leadership and followership grow together, or decline together.
If leadership is co-produced, the quality of following shapes the quality of leading. When followers ask real questions, name strengths and help design, leaders may grow more open, trusting and humble, and that invites fuller engagement in return. Researchers call this spiral reciprocal flourishing.1
The authors present reciprocal flourishing as a conceptual model; they do not claim to have measured it directly.1
- 6.1
It needs both sides
Followers can start it, but they cannot produce it alone. It depends on leaders who respond, and on structures that let contributions change what happens next.1
- 6.2
It works at two levels
Between people (trust, voice, shared authority) and across the system (structures, practices, outcomes).1
- 6.3
It can run backwards
Where voice is withheld and decisions are concentrated, the spiral turns downward: leaders grow more controlling or distant, and followers withdraw further.1
- 6.4
It is why change sticks
People who helped create a plan own it more deeply than people who were handed one.1
- 6.5
It looks outward too
Positive OD writers describe "mirror flourishing": organizations that work for flourishing beyond their walls may flourish within them. The cited support is limited; we hold it as a perspective, not a finding.6
Which kind of change does your situation call for?
Research on change leadership names three approaches and argues that two things decide among them: how complex the system is, and how well the problem and its solution are understood.3 We read both before we recommend one. Participation is our default, not our dogma.
- 7.1
Directed change
A fixed goal and a fast pace, with the leader deciding and persuading. It fits simpler problems whose answer is known.3
- 7.2
Planned change
A clear goal and a participative plan built with key stakeholders. It fits complex systems where the answer is broadly known.3
- 7.3
Iterative changing
A loose direction, with goal and process worked out together as people learn. It fits problems where neither the problem nor its answer is yet clear.3
The authors present all three as legitimate, and argue that large changes usually move between them over time, in a rhythm rather than a single choice.3
More on choosing an approach, with the change rhythmWhy new leaders become copies of old ones.
Leaders are often promoted for technical skill and given no development. They then learn leadership from the team they join, consciously or not. Leadership Clone Theory describes this mimicry, and how tribalism between leaders and staff can press a new leader to pick a side.2 The remedy combines dialogue, use of self, leadership development and team building, and it works best before promotion, not after the damage.
Cloning, tribalism, power over and power with, and what they cost an organization.
Read the full section, with its figuresUse of self is treating your own awareness as an instrument of change.
It means noticing your reactions, biases and influence as they happen, and choosing how to act, almost as if you could step outside yourself and watch.2 We practise it in every engagement, and we develop it in the leaders we work with.
- 9.1
Seeing your own part
Leaders who cannot see their own role in a breakdown tend to repeat it. Self-as-instrument work helps a new leader recognize that role, shed inherited habits and begin repairing the rift with staff.2
- 9.2
Seeing what is in front of you
Attention narrows, and details in plain view go unseen. Disciplined observation guards a diagnosis against inattentional blindness, and builds awareness of one's own biases in real time.2
- 9.3
Every word is an intervention
The words we use, the questions we ask and the strategies we suggest are themselves acts of leadership, so we choose them deliberately.6
- 9.4
Prepared before the room
Before a large participative event, we prepare the sponsoring leader on three fronts:7
- what the event is for and what success would look like;
- how they will meet their own anxiety and triggers in the moment;
- and how and when we will step in if they start to get in the way of their own intent.
Nine ways we work.
Every service runs on the Catalyst Cycle. Open one to see what we examine, what you receive, and the research behind it.
10.1Organizational assessment and diagnosisWhere you stand, established with evidence across the whole system.
What we examine
- All ten elements, and how each is acting on the others
- Whether each problem is technical or adaptive
- The gap between what the organization says it values and what happens day to day
- What is already working
- The unwritten cultural rules, and the sponsor's own expectations of how change should run
- Issues that pull against each other, so the ones no one raised come to the surface
- How followership shows up: who surfaces strengths, asks questions that open possibilities, and helps design solutions
What you receive
- An assessment report drawn from interviews, observation and records, with separate conversations by role group where candour needs it
- Strengths, gaps and risks, ranked
- A proposed plan with timelines, milestones and cost
Formats Scoped after the first conversation.
10.2Change implementationThe plan, designed and carried out with the people it affects.
What we examine
- Which approach the situation calls for (directed, planned or iterative), and the rhythm between them over time
- Who holds the knowledge the change needs
- Where participation turns into compliance, or into sham consultation
- Where a problem needs adaptive work by the people facing it, not a new rule
- The causes of resistance, which are several and call for different responses
What you receive
- An approach recommendation and a rhythm for the change
- Facilitated design sessions across levels
- Preparation for sponsoring leaders before participative events
- Cross-level teams to carry the work
- Progress reviews and measures
- A sustainment plan, so the effort does not end too soon
10.3Organizational turnaroundFor organizations in decline that need to recover direction, performance and financial footing.
What we examine
- The whole system, quickly
- What changed, and when
- The financial position, and what the organization can stop doing
- Which decisions must be directed now, and which can open up as the situation stabilizes
- The state of trust between leaders and staff
What you receive
- A rapid diagnosis
- A recovery plan, financial and organizational, with first priorities
- A clear statement of what is decided and what is open for input; we do not run staged participation
- Support for leaders through the recovery
In a turnaround, some decisions must be made quickly and by leaders, and directed change is legitimate under severe time pressure. We bring participation in wherever it can change the outcome.
10.4Executive coachingOne-to-one development for leaders, built on use of self.
What we examine
- Self-awareness, reflection and presence
- Your role in the system you lead
- Habits inherited from the leadership team you joined, and how you use power
- When you default to compliance or resistance yourself, and what a generative alternative would look like
- Which change approach a given moment calls for
- The words you use, the questions you ask and the strategies you suggest
What you receive
- Regular one-to-one coaching sessions
- Structured feedback and reflection, including practice in reflecting while acting
- A personal development plan
- Before major participative events: conceptual alignment, embodied self-scaffolding, and an agreement on how we will intervene, built on a relationship of trust
Formats A series of one-to-one sessions.
10.5Leadership and followership developmentLeadership is co-produced. We develop leading and following together, for everyone.
What we examine
- How leading and following happen across levels, not just in job titles
- Whether people can contribute beyond complying or resisting
- Whether leaders respond to, and share authority with, the knowledge around them
- How new leaders are prepared, before and after promotion
- Whether leadership is exercised by middle and first-line managers, not only at the top
- Whether "people programs" meet what staff need to contribute, or only what they want
What you receive
- Appreciative followership development, practised in real work
- Leadership development for new and existing leaders: use of self, emotional and cultural intelligence, and the foundations of leadership and organization design
- Development staged to experience, from directed support for people new to a role to collective leadership for experts
- Generative followership written into performance conversations and 360-degree reviews
- Structures that let follower knowledge shape decisions
More ways we work
- 10.6
Organization design
Structures, roles and decision rights that fit the work, including mergers and restructures.2,3,5
- 10.7
Team building
Teams that trust each other enough to do hard work together, with leadership and staff teams in the room where the rift runs between them.2
- 10.8
Workshops
Practice-based sessions that build a capability in the room. Half-day, full-day and two-day; in person and online.
- 10.9
Keynote speaking
We speak at conferences, board meetings, leadership retreats and all-staff gatherings, on the research behind our method.
Organizations of every kind.
The method is the same wherever people have to change how they work together. What changes is the context, and we learn it first.
Nonprofits
Boards, staff and volunteers aligned behind the mission, with every stakeholder's importance and position understood.5
Businesses
Growth, restructures, culture and leadership transitions, with the change approach matched to the situation.3
Churches and ministries
Congregational assessment, leadership transitions and seasons of change.
Through Chapter House, our practice for congregations and ministries.Schools and universities
Leadership teams, departments, governance and new strategies.
Public agencies
Goals are often disputed, authority is shared with boards and legislatures, decisions happen in public, and leaders' tenure can be short. Methods built for firms have to be rethought here.5
- Our experience
- More than a decade of work in community organizing, education partnerships and organization development, grounded in graduate study in divinity and organization development.
Chapter House, for congregations and ministries.
Chapter House is our practice for churches and ministries. It brings the Catalyst Cycle to congregational life: the same whole-system listening and the same participative design, in the language and rhythms of a worshipping community.
The practice draws on the graduate study in divinity and the years of community organizing behind our work. Congregations are not businesses, and we do not run them as if they were: we learn each community's own story, governance and calling first.
- 12.1
Congregational assessment
Listening across members, volunteers, staff and leaders, and reading mission, vision, leadership, culture and structure together.
- 12.2
Leadership transitions
Preparing a congregation and its leaders for a new pastor, a retiring founder or a changed board, before the change and through it.
- 12.3
Seasons of change
Mergers, relocations, decline and renewal, worked through with the people who will live with the outcome.
- 12.4
Boards, staff and volunteers together
Plans that elders, staff and volunteers help write, so the work does not rest on a few.
Tell us what needs to change.
Send a few lines about your organization and where things feel stuck. We will reply to arrange a first conversation.